Peter and the Starcatcher Cast

William Moreland (Captain Black Stache)
The magnificently browed and contentious Pirate Captain, who eventually becomes Captain Hook.
Samuel Seeman (Smee)
Black Stache’s desperately loyal right-hand man and a pessimistic pirate.
Brady Oropesa (Alf)
A seafarer on the Neverland, seemingly rough but with a soft, tender side who can charm the lady of the ship.
Lexi D’Aleo (Molly Aster)
The 13-year-old daughter of Lord Leonard Aster, she is a natural, fearless leader who is devoted to her father and strives to become a Starcatcher just like him.
Erin Fitzgerald (Betty Bumbrake)
The no-nonsense, older nanny of Molly Aster. British to the bone and not afraid of anything, but she still has her girlish charm.
Patrick Lone (Lord Leonard Aster)
The devoted Father of Molly, and a dedicated Starcatcher, determined to serve the Queen and protect the earth. The perfect example of a Victorian English Gentleman.
Chloe Wright (Prentiss)
An ambitious orphan, who is older than the others, she believes she is the leader of the other orphans trapped on the ship.
Luis Ramirez (Ted)
An orphan called “Tubby” by Prentiss because he is food obsessed, particularly bread pudding.
Ryder Stroud (Captain Slank)
The cruel and ruthless Captain of the Neverland, who is terrible at leading his crew; although once an orphan himself, he has no sympathy for them now.
Chelsea Mathews (Fighting Prawn)
Queen of Mollusk Island, who was once captured by the British and forced to be a cook before her escape. She now hates all British.
Caleb Davilmar (Boy/Peter)
A nameless, friendless orphan shipped off on the Neverland who later becomes the competitive and heroic Peter Pan.
Madison Sanders (Mack)
A seafarer who doesn’t know her port from her starboard, deathly afraid of her Captain, Bill Slank.
Rowen Smith (Pirate Sanchez)
A Spanish Pirate who hates that Captain Black Stache can never get her name right.
Madison Settembrino (Teacher)
A scotch salmon which turned into a scholarly mermaid after swimming through Starstuff who gives advice to Peter and the last name, “Pan.”
Story Truss (Headmistress Grempkin)
The mean, cruel headmistress of the orphanage where Ted, Prentiss, and Peter were put. She whips the terrified orphans and sells them to Bill Slank.
Mia Harms (Captain Scott)
The Captain of the Wasp, the fastest ship in the Sea, and a longtime friend of Aster.
Isaque Bessa (Ensemble)
Plays multiple characters like a pirate, a seafarer, a mollusk islander, and a narrator.
Juliana Lonetta (Ensemble)
Plays multiple characters like a pirate, a seafarer, a mollusk islander, and a narrator.
Laura Johnson (Ensemble)
Plays multiple characters like a pirate, a seafarer, a mollusk islander, and a narrator.
Olivia Oropesa (Ensemble)
Plays multiple characters like a pirate, a seafarer, a mollusk islander, and a narrator.
Reese Mathis (Ensemble)
Plays multiple characters like a pirate, a seafarer, a mollusk islander, and a narrator.
Layton McCartney (Student Director)
Stephen Seckinger (Stage Manager)
Jacob Payner (Assistant Stage Manager)