Meet the sweetest little old ladies you’ll ever adore… who just happen to have a very unusual hobby. In Arsenic and Old Lace, charm and chaos collide as love, family, and a few too many “house guests” turn one Brooklyn home into the most delightfully dangerous place on earth. Come for the laughs, stay for the surprises—and maybe think twice before accepting homemade elderberry wine.

Arsenic and Old Lace – Cast List

Abby Brewster – Hattie Hubbard

Martha Brewster – Eliza Jackson

Mortimer Brewster – Max Kendall

Elaine Harper – Nyana Johnson

Jonathan Brewster – Maclay Skeen

Dr. Einstein – Max Brown

Teddy Brewster – Mikey Hibbert

Mr. Witherspoon – Nick Perkins 

Officer Brophy – Elmer Aguilar

Officer Klein – Brooklyn Lowell 

Officer O’Hara – Grant Lewis

Mr. Gibbs – Kerrigan Heilman

Rev. Dr. Harper – Lee Cerda

Lieutenant Rooney – Grace Bird